The hard ones

Perimenopause and Depression: What a Husband Gets Wrong

A wife lying flat on the couch while her husband sits on the floor beside her, back against the couch, just there

In our house, happiness was always something we treated as a choice.

Not in a hard nosed, suck it up way. Just a belief I carried into the marriage and into raising our kids. You choose your framing, you choose your words, and that flows through into how you carry yourself. We caught ourselves when we slipped. That was just how our family worked.

So when I started seeing real sadness in her, not a flat mood, not a bad day, I didn't have a shelf to put it on.

My instinct was that she had simply stopped choosing to be happy.

Does perimenopause cause depression?

I'm going to be careful here, because the word matters.

Depression is a doctor's word. No doctor ever said it to me about my wife, and I'm not going to say it about her now. What I saw in our house was sadness with nothing attached to it. Tears from nowhere. Days where the light went out of her and she couldn't tell me why, because there wasn't a why.

Her body was going through a hormonal, biological change. Two of the big hormones, oestrogen and progesterone, have a hand in the parts of her that look after mood, and through these years they rise and fall with no pattern and over time they drop. When the one that helps keep her mood level stops turning up, the mood doesn't stay level. That much anyone can read.

Whether what's happening in your house is that, or something that needs its own name and its own help, is not a call for you or me. That's a doctor or a specialist in this field, and you go with her if she wants you there.

If she's talking about not wanting to be here, that's today, not next week. Lifeline is there any hour on 13 11 14. Ring it with her, or for her, and get her in front of a doctor or a specialist in this field today.

What did I get wrong?

I built a case.

Over the next few days after the tears, I looked around at our life and did the sums. We've got our health. We've got each other. A roof over our heads, people who love us. There's no reason for this.

The case was airtight. It was also completely useless, because sadness that arrives without a reason was never going to be solved by evidence. I'd mistaken a weather system for an argument I could win.

And underneath the case was the quieter thing. I thought she'd stopped choosing. Which meant, somewhere in my head, I thought she could choose her way back if she wanted to. That's the mistake. Not the case. The idea that she had a say in it.

Is it sadness, or is it something more?

I don't know, and the whole point of this post is that you don't either.

The tears have their own post. Waking up scared with nothing wrong has its own. The flat, worn down weeks have theirs. All of those were ours, and all of them lifted on their own eventually, the way weather does.

If yours isn't lifting, if it's deepening, if it's changing how she eats or sleeps or talks about herself, stop reading husbands on the internet. Go with her. You can be the bloke who didn't wait for the word.

What should I say when my wife is sad for no reason?

Here's one of the tools. There are plenty.

Do you want help sorting this, or do you just want me to listen right now?

One question. Asked beside her, not across from her. Then whatever she says, take it and run with it.

If she says listen, you listen. You don't sneak a fix in at the end. You don't bring the case. You don't say there's no reason to be sad, because she knows that better than you do, and it's the thing frightening her most.

If she says help, then you help with the thing she names, not the thing you've decided is the problem.

Most days in our house the answer was listen. Some days it was neither, and she just wanted me in the room. That counts.

What I do on the Overcast days now, one of the five weather patterns we use in our house, flat and tired and going through the motions, and how I learned to stop being the man with the case, is in the book. The chapter is called The Tears She Couldn't Explain.

Does it lift?

Ours did, every time, and I stopped being able to take credit for that, because it was never my case that lifted it.

What I could take credit for was whether she was alone while it was heavy. For a couple of years she was. She isn't now.

If the word depression is in your head tonight, say it to a doctor before you say it to her. And sit beside her while you wait for the appointment.

Start With the Weather

The Weather Report is the two-page guide to reading these days: telling a storm warning from an overcast day from a fog day, and knowing the one thing to do in each. Free, on your phone in thirty seconds.

Get the free Weather Report